By Carole Reedy
A book is a device to spark the imagination.
Allan Bennet
In terms of Bennet’s observation, I found this year of reading disappointingly lacking. Each new season we seek a great read, but what exactly are we looking for?
Novels are rich in character development, have an engaging plot with vivid descriptions of the ambiance of period or place, and possess a distinct writing style. Well executed, these characteristics allow the reader to emotionally connect with the author’s themes, leading to reflection long after the final word is read.
In light of my general dissatisfaction (though a few novels made it into my forthcoming column), I turned to some other genres: the short story for one, as well as essays and series. Here I found the literary satisfaction I was seeking.
Savory Series
One might think a series is merely a collection of novels, but for the reader gratification relies on continuing character development along with detailed, continuing stories of the characters’ lives that cannot be achieved in a single volume.
The following five series, which will take you around the world, provide all of the elements needed for a deeply satisfying season of reading.
The Shetland Island Mysteries by Anne Cleeves
This remote and modest part of the world provides more action and richly developed characters than you might expect. The isolation of the islands and their harsh weather and barren landscape all play roles in the psyche of the population as well as providing an eerie ambiance.
I’m guessing you’ll get hooked on the characters, beautifully crafted throughout the series. Cleeves has a style and method that is simply compelling. Readers of the series have even been inspired to put the Shetland Islands on their travel list.
Cleeves has two other series to enjoy: the Vera Stanhope and Matthew Venn series. All three of Cleeves’ series have been adapted for TV.
The Leaphorn, Chee, and Manuelito Novels by Anne Hillerman
We are fortunate that Anne Hillerman’s mother and friends encouraged her to continue writing her father’s Navajo tribal police series.
The revered writer Tony Hillerman (1925-2008) and his fictional Navajo Nation detectives Joe Leaphorn and Jim Chee charmed mystery lovers in the 1970s, 80s,and 90s. Hillerman’s close field of vision of this Native American population contributed mightily to the popularity of the series. Through his deeply felt descriptions of Navajo culture, Hillerman brought us a new vision of the first Americans.
Anne Hillerman’s earnest effort to continue the series has been a wondrous surprise to fans. She has successfully added detective Bernadette Manuelito (Jim Chee’s wife) to the series, giving her room to be a forceful character in her own right. Manuelito’s relationship with her mother, sister, and Chee adds an exciting new element to the detective unit as well as to the personal lives of the old favorites.
The series re-creates the world of American native citizens of Arizona and New Mexico. The plot weaves in the age-old traditions and beliefs of the people of the southwest in a way that’s engaging and educational. The vivid imagery is so powerful it feels as though the dust might settle on your tongue.
The Sean Duffy Series by Adrian McKinty
McKinty’s hero arrives in the unlikely figure of Belfast Detective Sean Duffy, an independent thinker and rule breaker, not traits usually found in Ulster policemen.
But McKinty’s style is pure genius.
Even if you’re not personally connected to history’s violent political environment of Northern Ireland, the eerie atmosphere of the region and the affairs of the population will entrap you…and Sean Duffy will eventually charm you.
The Commissario Guido Brunetti Mysteries by Donna Leon
All 33 (so far) novels take place in the ethereal state of Venice, in the mysteriously diverse country of Italy, where detective Commissario Guido Brunetti leads a small group of police that attempts to solve myriad crimes in their district.
However, and this is key, the mysteries always entail more than simply a crime.
Leon gives us sharp glimpses into the social and practical aspects of daily Venetian life. Her characterizations, not only of the police and perpetrators but of Brunetti’s family, are brilliantly colorful in depth and intensity.
Societal and political issues and concerns of the city, as well as other parts of the country, lurk in the background of whatever crime the team is investigating. A few of the novels particularly impressed me with their richness of commentary on Venetian society and personal concerns: Willful Behavior, Friends in High Places, A Noble Radiance, and Uniform Justice.
The Ruth Galloway Novels by Elly Griffiths
It’s nearly impossible to write about favorite series without a shoutout to Elly Griffiths and her memorable archaeologist professor Dr Ruth Galloway, who analyzes buried bones found in Norwich.
Galloway inadvertently (or not) finds herself in the middle of various crime investigations when the bones her archeological students find are not centuries old, but newly emerged. And police investigations ensue.
The real joy in reading this series lies in Griffiths’ keen characterizations—of Dr Ruth Galloway, Detective Nelson, and the Druid Cathbad among others.
Satisfying Short Story Collections
Good and Evil and Other Stories by Samanta Schweblin, translated by Megan McDowell
Argentine writer Schweblin has already tasted success with her 2014 National Book Award-winning Seven Empty Houses. And now this, her latest, is receiving accolades from many sources, most importantly from the prolific Joyce Carol Oates in The New York Times Book Review.
Oates sums it up: “Beautifully translated by Megan McDowell, in prose that shimmers with a sort of menacing lyricism, the stories of ‘Good and Evil’ are powerfully evocative and unsettling. They seem to hover, indeed like fever dreams, between the reassuring familiarities of domestic life and the stark, unpredictable, visionary flights of the unconscious. Everything exists in a state of tension, charged with contradictions.”
Each story, though unique, possesses an unnerving surprise, never taking the expected path.
Dictation by Cynthia Ozick
Recommended by a fellow book club member, I immediately downloaded this quartet of stories. The mention of Henry James and Joseph Conrad as characters in the first story prompted my automatic interest.
Nonetheless, the stars of this short story are the women who take dictation from the masters. The finale is astonishing yet plausible. The other three stories, though without the notable characters of the first, are equally deserving of praise.
Part two of the Best Books of 2025 next month will offer a glimpse into the handful of novels I read in 2025 that satisfied my reading obsession.
You must be logged in to post a comment.